[ONGOING] Magical Girl, sing me a melody: Finding personal connection between the Mahou Shoujo genre and Kpop Girl Groups

I want you to make contracts with me and become Magical Girls! I'm getting lost in a maze. Don't be fooled by a shining fake. Oh please stop. Oh please stop. If it cannot break out of its shell, the chick will die without being born. We are the chick, the world is our egg. If we don't crack the world's shell, we will die without being born. Smash the world's shell, for the revolution of the world! Open your eyes wide, you’re about to crash, stop the speeding. Be the witness of change. When everyone is being quiet. In front of the rough caterpillar that is being pushed. Beautiful. All this suffering at the moment of destruction. I suppose you have no choice but to revolutionize the world. The way before you has been prepared. Can’t you come greet me? Then I would hurry even more and have strength. Forever imprisoned on the stage, her brilliance made to dance, until her life reaches its end. A new world will be opened to us. You’re my destiny. The gravity that pulls me. I can’t look away. You’re all I see. You’re my destiny. I can never leave you. You’re my Earth. The center of my day. The star we had always longed for was our starlight.
Ever since discovering magical girls through Sailor Moon, and Kpop through Girls' Generation (both pioneers), I've come to become engrossed in the experience both offered me. One rabbit hole led to another and my appreciation and knowledge about both topics grew and I eventually started noticing references/similarities between the two. The exploration of genres and concepts, focus on female relationships, flashy cool customized outfits, the music in all its glory-how could I not be hooked?
From Mahou shoujo inspired Kpop groups like Orange Caramel, AOA Cream, WJSN, GFRIEND, Lovelyz, LOONA, to Idol/performance adjecent magical girl shows like Full Moon Wo Sagashite, Mermaid Melody, Revue Starlight, Pretty Rhythm, and Aikatsu-the interchangeability between both appealed heavily to child me.
Even as an adult, I still hold the 2 topics dear to me and can admit proudly they have shaped a part of who I am today. Throughout my journey of consuming both Kpop girl group content and Magical girl shows, I've come to notice the rise in exploring concepts and genres that exceeded its usual tropes. Of course, along with this came with being more aware of the reality of certain industries, and come to analyze deeper beyond its face value.
My exposure to Madoka Magica+Revolutionary Girl Utena and LOONA+f(x) goes hand in hand with how both allowed me to experience fresher takes within a genre that offered enjoyable, but sometimes repetitive ideas. Of course, I also understand the idea that nothing is completely original which also applies to Kpop or Magical Girls-and they both come from the same base. But how it's executed or added onto with personal interpretation or experiences is what gets me.
I still have a special place in my heart for the classics or more "safer" content within the Kpop GG or Magical Girl genre. I love me my Precure, Winx, and Tokyo Mewmew. Or some cutesie TWICE, Crayon Pop, or Dalshabet. Comparing those to Utena, Madoka, or Princess Tutu and Brown Eyed Girls, Stellar, or EXID-of course you notice a difference. The range within both is also part of what I enjoy, sometimes you can enjoy the more lighthearted and if you're in the mood you can also indulge in heavier themes/backstories.
In both Magical girls and Kpop girl groups, despite its positive, lovely appearance-I've come to focus on what goes on behind the curtains. To be more aware of all sides, and thinking about the human experiences behind the very thing we consume. I ultimately contradict my previous paragraph by saying this, but in doing so I realize that Kpop Girl Groups and Magical Girls are actually not so lighthearted at all.
Between the two of course the key difference is that one is rooted in fantasy while others focus on real life people. But there are still overlaps to be found in the industry and system that builds the girls up. One of many overarching themes that ties it both is the capitalist aspect of both sides. Think: Kyubey=company CEOs.
Both allows us to enter an experience built around female empowerment, constant transformations, relationship dynamics, and dazzling performances. But once you take a step back, you start to see contradictions within the genre/industry. Which is the the fact that the very system and forces that allows the girls to have their new found power and recognizability are the ones that bind them to a contract filled with expectations and ultimately to become products of consumption. Once you peel back the layers, you start to question the morality of both sides.
Madoka Magica, slave contracts, and high expectations
Both magical girls and kpop girls go through some form of recruitment/training and have to have this image or quota to keep up.
Ofc kpop idols go into the indtsry still knowing what theyre getting into. To question or challenge why the industry like this in the first place. Which is deep rooted in decades of misogyny, money hungry corporations, oversaturation of a market and more.
Identity as consumption
Alter egos/transformations
Girl Power/Queerness within groups
Good vs. Evil
Femininity vs Forced Image
LOONA, ARTMS and Utena
A group worth mentioning is LOONA, stylized as LOOΠΔ. You can read more extensively about them here: Credits to Infizero The well thought out executed lore, storylines, and music of the group is considered a rare art in Kpop.
LOONA has offered us this magical experience but of course we cant overlook the group having unfortunate end due to their company mistreating them which caused them to disband and go their separate ways. Some are solo, some in groups, some inactive. Unfortunate reality of situation, nothing much we can do. Most we can do is boycott and actively let their stories know. and support their current activities to the best of one's abiltiies/time.
This doesn't change the fact that we have consumed content from the group as they were in pain. With LOONA it’s once again a reminder that despite the art a group can put out and inspire many others, it still comes with having to come to terms with the industry and system as a whole and how it is underlying with exploitative labor, manufactured, systematic harmful beliefs implemented upon members and fans.
I'm glad the girls have broken free from such a toxic, predatory, horrible company that is Blockberry Creative (Curse you bro). Even if may mean the members may not be able to reunite and come together under the LOONA name. Their story, lore, and influence continues to live on. The girls are regaining control of their creative voices and identity within a harsh industry, and I am so proud of them.
Gender/sexuality, patriarchy, trauma/abuse, symbolism between LOONA and Utena is a personal interpretation
If we completely rid of the very beings that allowed these groups to form, they would not even exist and we wouldn't be able to enjoy them in any way. But it is moreso to be able to differentiate between the appreciation vs. delusion, and the extent to how much we prop up members/magical girls within a harmful system.
Personal Note: We can look at society as magical beings as a whole, and that in reality, we're all just trying to survive and make our dreams come true in such a fast paced, overwhelming world. There is no final boss, or a wand to solve all your problems. Get beat down by life, get back up again. Keep living. To transcend and redefine what it means to be the "ideal being." Find it within yourself.